Cases are decided on documents, and most documents are now electronic. They are created automatically and deleted automatically.
By the time a claim is issued, the most useful evidence may already be gone. The period before litigation is when preservation matters most, and when it is most often neglected.
The duty starts earlier than most people expect
The obligation to preserve relevant evidence arises when litigation is reasonably anticipated. That can be well before a claim is served. A demand letter, a credible threat, a serious internal complaint or your own decision to sue can each be enough.
Intentionally destroying relevant evidence after that point is spoliation. In July 2026 the Supreme Court of Canada restated the law in a commercial case from Ontario (SS&C Technologies Canada Corp v Bank of New York Mellon Corp, 2026 SCC 29). Spoliation is made out where evidence was intentionally destroyed, altered or concealed, litigation was ongoing or reasonably contemplated, the evidence was relevant, and it is reasonable to infer the destruction was meant to affect the litigation.
Once that is shown, the court presumes the missing evidence would have hurt the party responsible. If the presumption is not rebutted, the court must draw an adverse inference capable of filling the gap. Other sanctions remain available, including costs, striking a pleading and contempt. In that case, the defendant had been asked to preserve its usage data and had declined.
Loss of evidence that falls short of spoliation can still have consequences in costs and procedure (McDougall v Black & Decker Canada Inc, 2008 ABCA 353).
A routine deletion policy is fine until litigation is foreseeable. After that, letting it run is a decision.
The litigation hold
A hold is a set of instructions to stop evidence from disappearing.
Identify the people. Who sent, received or stored anything relevant?
Send a written notice. In plain language, say what to keep and that nothing is to be deleted.
Suspend automatic deletion. Email retention limits, chat platforms, disappearing messages, backup rotation, phone settings.
Secure departing employees' devices and accounts before they are wiped and reissued.
Look beyond the office systems. Personal phones used for work, cloud storage, code repositories, security footage that is overwritten in days.
Record what was done and when. You may need to prove it.
Preserve it properly
Opening, forwarding or copying a file can change its metadata. For devices that matter, have a qualified examiner take a forensic image and document the chain of custody.
The same care applies to evidence of what the other side is doing. Capture web pages with their addresses and dates. Make test purchases and keep the packaging and receipts. Infringing listings have a way of vanishing once a demand letter arrives.
Mind the privilege
Documents from an internal investigation are not automatically privileged. Litigation privilege protects material created for the dominant purpose of litigation (Blank v Canada (Minister of Justice), 2006 SCC 39; Lizotte v Aviva Insurance Company of Canada, 2016 SCC 52).
Involving counsel early, and having counsel retain the forensic examiner, puts the business in a better position to claim that protection.
Preserving the other side's evidence
A preservation letter. It puts the other side on notice and sets up an argument for an adverse inference if evidence later goes missing. The trade-off is that it warns them.
An Anton Piller order. Where there is strong evidence that a defendant will destroy material, a court can authorize a supervised search. It is exceptional and closely controlled.
A Norwich order. Where a bank, platform or service provider holds the information, a court can order disclosure before the data is purged.
Preserve broadly, produce narrowly
Preservation is not production. Keeping everything that might be relevant costs little. What is later reviewed and produced is governed by relevance and proportionality.
The mistake to avoid is treating the two as the same decision, and deleting now what you assume you would never have to produce.
This post is general information about Canadian law. It is not legal advice about your situation.

